• Best of Web
  • Home
  • Classics
  • Blog
  • Radio
  • Heroes
  • Books
  • Quotes
  • Talks
  • News
  • About
Menu

Lawrence W. Reed

  • Best of Web
  • Home
  • Classics
  • Blog
  • Radio
  • Heroes
  • Books
  • Quotes
  • Talks
  • News
  • About
Jefferson.jpg

Jefferson on Debt: He Warned Us!

December 7, 2020

In the eight years of his presidency (1801-1809), did he practice what he preached? To a remarkable extent, yes he did.

Read More

Jefferson Warned Us About Debt

 

By Lawrence W. Reed

 

“The deterioration of every government,” wrote the French philosopher Montesquieu more than 250 years ago, “begins with the decay of the principles on which it was founded.”

 

No one expressed more eloquently the principles on which America was founded than the prime author of the Declaration of Independence and the country’s third president, Thomas Jefferson. As the country’s national debt soars under both major political parties, I ask myself, “What would Jefferson think?”

 

In 1981, the country’s national debt crossed the $1 trillion-mark for the first time. It took another 15 years to get to $5 trillion. In February 2019, less than two years ago, it stood at $22 trillion. Today, it’s $27 trillion, which means we’ve added as much additional debt in nominal terms in two years as we did in our first 220 years as a nation.

 

If you think the debt has simply kept pace with population or inflation, think again. According to the consumer price index, prices today are roughly 216 percent higher than in 1980. Population is 70 percent higher than forty years ago. The national debt, meanwhile, exploded by 2,700 percent over the same period. And this does not include a penny of the long-term, unfunded liabilities of the U.S. government, which exceed $100 trillion and which will translate into mountains of new debt as the spending it requires kicks in.

 

The genius from Virginia had much to say about debt. What a shame that his advice is often quoted these days but rarely followed. “I place economy among the first and most important republican virtues,” he declared, “and public debt as the greatest of the dangers to be feared.”

 

Even in his own day, Jefferson was offering advice that unfortunately did not make it to first base. Consider how much better off we might be today if this little gem of an idea from him had been accepted when the Constitution was written: “But with respect to future debt, would it not be wise and just for that nation to declare in the constitution they are forming that neither the legislature, nor the nation itself, can validly contract more debt than they may pay within their own age, or within the term of 19 years?”

 

Nonetheless, Jefferson’s view that debt should be minimal was widely held by America’s early chief executives. His successor, James Madison, once said, “I go on the principle that public debt is a public curse.” He refused to go into debt to pay the costs of the War of 1812. And it was under our seventh president, Andrew Jackson, that the national debt briefly disappeared altogether (a feat not to be repeated in the eighteen decades since).

 

Perhaps Jefferson’s strongest admonition on the issue came in these wise words:

 

We must not let our rulers load us with perpetual debt. We must make our election between economy and liberty or profusion and servitude….A departure from principle in one instance becomes a precedent for another till the bulk of society is reduced to be mere automatons of misery...And the fore-horse of this frightful team is public debt. Taxation follows, and in its train, wretchedness and oppression.

 

OK, you say, all this is easier said than done. Maybe Jefferson was like most politicians who promise fiscal integrity but deliver profligacy and debt. In the eight years of his presidency (1801-1809), did he practice what he preached?

 

To a remarkable extent, yes he did. Despite the huge expense of the Louisiana Purchase (which roughly doubled the country’s size), the national debt fell by one-third during Jefferson’s presidency. Tariffs rose but other taxes (mostly excise taxes on whiskey and other commodities) were actually cut. As Mike Maharry wrote in his 2019 article, “How Jefferson Handled the National Debt” (https://buildingblocksforliberty.org/2019/03/how-thomas-jefferson-handled-the-national-debt/),

 

Jefferson limited federal spending, keeping total outlays flat at between $8 and $10 million throughout his presidency. The Democrat-Republicans held costs down by cutting the federal bureaucracy. And they even managed to do this with a federal workforce totaling just 130 employees.

 

Sometimes the debt is flippantly dismissed by declaring, “we owe it to ourselves.” That’s a beguiling but ridiculous statement echoed by economic charlatans from Franklin Roosevelt to John Maynard Keynes to Paul Krugman. For a refutation, see this 2018 article by Bart Remes: https://fee.org/articles/debt-doesnt-matter-because-we-owe-it-to-ourselves-why-krugman-and-keynes-are-wrong-about-this/. “We” and “ourselves,” Remes points out, are not the same.

 

Back to my question, “What would Jefferson think” about a $27 trillion national debt? I’ll venture to say he would be shocked and appalled. He would likely judge us poor stewards of the public purse, oblivious to the burden that today’s spending is foisting on future generations. He would probably say we are either drunk or mad for convincing ourselves that too much debt is nothing to worry about.

 

And, like so many of that wise founding generation, he would be precisely right.

← Words & Numbers: "The Adventures of Larry Reed," December 2020Freedom's Future →

Recent “Best of Web”

Featured
Corrupt Government Officials Who Have Been Arrested For The Russia Collusion Hoax
Aug 1, 2025
Corrupt Government Officials Who Have Been Arrested For The Russia Collusion Hoax
Aug 1, 2025

Updated with each arrest.

Aug 1, 2025
New York May Get Government-Owned Grocery Stores
Jul 8, 2025
New York May Get Government-Owned Grocery Stores
Jul 8, 2025

“Mamdani’s plan to carve a substantial portion out of NYC’s food market for ‘public’ grocers, with no way of gauging their effectiveness, is a foolhardy attempt to coax voters into supporting socialism, rather than a realistic effort to help New Yorkers,” writes Connor Vasile.

Jul 8, 2025
Thanks To Public School Funding Cuts, This Five-Year-Old Student Doesn't Know All The Variant Sexual Lusts Adults Can Have
May 20, 2025
Thanks To Public School Funding Cuts, This Five-Year-Old Student Doesn't Know All The Variant Sexual Lusts Adults Can Have
May 20, 2025

Young Logan Traylor was nearing the end of his kindergarten experience and, despite the public education system's best efforts, was discovered to have absolutely no knowledge about the shocking fetishes and perverted interests grown-ups engage in — Babylon Bee.

May 20, 2025

Recent Quotes

Featured
Murphy on America
Feb 11, 2025
Murphy on America
Feb 11, 2025

“The true meaning of America, you ask? It’s in a Texas rodeo, in a policeman’s badge, in the sound of laughing children, in a political rally, in a newspaper. ... In all these things, and many more, you’ll find America. In all these things, you’ll find freedom. And freedom is what America means to the world. And to me” — Actor, poet, and the most decorated American of World War II, Audie Murphy.

Feb 11, 2025
Mill on Freedom
Feb 1, 2025
Mill on Freedom
Feb 1, 2025

“The only freedom which deserves the name is that of pursuing our own good in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, or impede their efforts to obtain it. Each is the proper guardian of his own health, whether bodily, or mental and spiritual. Mankind are greater gainers by suffering each other to live as seems good to themselves than by compelling each to live as seems good to the rest.”

Feb 1, 2025
Best-Selling Japanese Novelist Eiji Yoshikawa on Do-Gooders
Mar 20, 2023
Best-Selling Japanese Novelist Eiji Yoshikawa on Do-Gooders
Mar 20, 2023

“There’s nothing more frightening than a half-baked do-gooder who knows nothing of the world but takes it upon himself to tell the world what’s good for it — from his book, Musashi.

Mar 20, 2023

Recent Blogs

Featured
Jesus, Pigs, and Private Property
Aug 8, 2025
Jesus, Pigs, and Private Property
Aug 8, 2025

Jesus did not steal the pigs; the demons did. It was the nature and choice of the demons that led to the destruction of the pigs they possessed. The story does not contradict Jesus’s teachings regarding private property. (AI-generated audio discussion attached.)

Aug 8, 2025
Stan the Man
Aug 7, 2025
Stan the Man
Aug 7, 2025

Thank you, Poland, for giving us the Musial family. May we never forget what a fantastic example of sterling character that Stan the Man was! (Photo credit: By Bowman Gum.)

Aug 7, 2025
A VERY Special Film
Aug 5, 2025
A VERY Special Film
Aug 5, 2025

This year—2025—marks the Diamond anniversary (60 years) of a movie that set the trajectory of my professional life.

Aug 5, 2025